TV SERIES Review – Star Trek: Picard S1E2 – Maps and Legends ⭐️⭐️½

Season 1
Episode 2 – “Maps and Legends”

14 years ago on a Mars construction outpost a bald synthetic is teased by his co-workers. A minute later we see him going all Data-like with super speedy hands on a computer screen.

The human workers try to stop him and he pulls out some sort of phaser-like device and kills all of them.

Onto the title screen.

We’re now 7+ minutes into 46 minute episode before we see Picard on screen. He’s already deep into the investigation of what happened to Dahj and it’s leading him to something called the Jaqblas (?spelling?), sort of a new world boogeyman with the help of his two caretakers discussing the background of the Jaqblas.

The investigation leads to a communication with Dahj but — insert dramatic beat — it is happening off world.

Cut to another scene with Dahj’s sister aboard a Borg cube known as The Artifact. Dahj’s sister has a co-worker and boyfriend, so they are in bed and it’s some kind of galactic pillow talk. Almost a complete throwaway scene.

Back to Picard who is getting a house call from his doctor. Picard wants to get approved for interstellar service, but the news isn’t good.

Picard finds out from his doctor that his time could be limited — he is in his 90s

This would be a good time for Picard to consult Number One his pitbul, but the dog is nowhere to be seen in episode 2. Picard’s medscreens came back good except for an abnormality in his brain. Does he have some form of dementia? The prognosis isn’t good. Whatever Picard has in his brain is terminal.

Picard wants to be certified as fit for interstellar service. An old Stargazer doctor friend, will he help Picard?

Picard visits Starfleet as a visitor and sees Admiral Clancy to ask for permission for temporary reinstatement — one mission – so that he can try and track down where Dahj twin sister is located.

Picard’s legendary deductive powers have him believing that Maddox was out there using some of Data’s positronic components to create sythetics. Picard also believes Maddox used Data’s painting of Dahj as a starting reference for the synths.

A heated exchange ensues.

Picard’s request is quickly denied with Clancy rudely barking at Picard: “Do what you’re good at: go home!”

And thus from this moment, Picard must decide if he goes rogue. Does he? You’ll have to watch the rest of the episode to see what happens.

My Review

This episode feels more like an episode of a soap opera than Star Trek. The structure is such that there is a large amount of exposition fed into very little dramatic tension. No action, save for the opening scene on Mars that is a flashback.

We’re treated to a little bit of Picard in Sherlock Holmes mode, some synth revolt 14 years ago on Mars, some more on Picard’s tense relationship with Starfleet, a teaser on what Dahj’s sister is up to on the Borg cube and then the absolute most interesting part of the episode (as was the case last week): a trailer of what’s coming in future episodes!

This episode just comes off feeling like a bunch of backstory being crammed into viewer’s brains. Sure, we’ll need some of it later in the story, but do we need it all right now? Some of it is repeating material we got in the first episode.

Picard visiting an old “friend” with a bottle of wine

We need to hurry up and get Picard on some kind of ship with a crew (teased in the trailer at the end of the first episode) and off earth. That is when maybe the “Star Trek” part of this show will become justified.

When Picard is on earth this show is, from a pacing perspective, going in reverse. It’s just … OK. Very slow moving, unfortunately. I liked the trailer at the end more than the episode. Felt too much like info dump, less about action, adventure and forward movement.

Overall episode rating: ⭐️⭐️½

Later this morning (7am PST), The Ready Room will be on YouTube with a behind the second season episode hosted by Wil Wheaton (Wesley Crusher!) and that might be as good or better than the actual episode. I’ll embed that below with additional thoughts on that.


Episode #2 of The Ready Room is embedded below. Suggest you watch the episode first before streaming this episode.

Learn more about the Borg Cube Artifact in this in depth behind the scenes look at S1:E2 “Maps and Ladders”

3 thoughts on “TV SERIES Review – Star Trek: Picard S1E2 – Maps and Legends ⭐️⭐️½

    1. Thank you for taking time to comment. The Ready Room on YouTube has a really good discussion about Picard that suggests to me that the direction Patrick Stewart wants to portray as a heavy part of the narrative is that of a senior citizen Picard, the haunting behind the loss of his friend Data which wasn’t nearly as dramatic as it should have been in NEMESIS (since my memory of that movie was that it was one of the worst feature films they put out in the series). I’m interested in this story, but am questioning just how “Star Trek” that story is. Maybe it would have been better to not have the “Star Trek” in the title and just make it some sort of spin-off called The Haunting of Jean Luc Picard or something? Will be interesting to see how this plays out over the two seasons.

      So far it seems like that *IS* the direction they are headed. To solve this grand mystery of why the synths went rogue. I’m pondering how they could to this story and be more Star Trek and the answer I keep returning to would be going from world to world on a ship solving different problems with the prime directive in tact and yet also solving this synth mystery — kind of like how Q was handled in STNG. That would seem more Star Trek to me and keep the focus off of Picard being frail, old and on his deathbed.

      Let’s hope next week we see Picard on a ship again. That will definitely feel more Star Trek.


      1. Wow, long reply.

        Yeah, hopefully it does feel like classic Star Trek soon! Thanks for taking the time to chat. Just released a new post and am ready to eat pizza and crash on my bed.

        Keep up the great work man! 👍

        Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s